https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-0XR6Y9027Qscript>

Deutsche Bank 2008 AGM 'Void'?

4 September 2009

Sarah Wilson

EU regulation

Press reports today suggest that Leo Kirch is likely to participate in mediation talks with Deutsche Bank in an effort to resolve his long-running dispute with the company.

Earlier this week, the Landgericht in Frankfurt (a local court), found in Kirch's favour, and the ruled that most of the decisions of the 2008 AGM are void. In particular, the choice of auditor and the supervisory board and their discharge and the decision on the use of retained earnings are annulled. Deutsche Banks has stated that it intends to appeal to the Oberlandsgericht (a higher instance, provincial court) in Frankfurt, which has already supported DB in same cases twice since 2003. However the capital increases approved at the meeting were allowed by the High Court in an emergency procedure and are not impacted by the decision. If Oberlandsgericht supports the ruling of Landgericht, the case will go to the German Supreme Court, whose ruling will be final.

Back in 2002, the CEO of Deutsche Bank, Rolf Breuer gave a television interview in which he said it was "questionable" whether Mr. Kirch would be able to refinance billions of euros of debt. This pushed Kirch Group to file for bankruptcy. Kirch sued the bank claiming that Breuer had violated German laws that prohibit bankers from making public statements about the financial situation of their clients.

Deutsche Bank last year fired its German head of corporate security and its head of investor relations after the bank was revealed to have hired private detectives to monitor executives including chief operating officer Lamberti, an employee representative Gerald Herrmann, and Michael Bohndorf an investor who had previously sued the Bank. The investigation into Bohndorf was  in order to determine whether he was connected with Mr Kirch.

A suspected infiltration of the law firm, Bub, Gauweiler & Partner, who were acting for Kirch, has also raised questions as to the bank's behaviour.

After Deutsche Bank disclosed the matter in May, it commissioned New York law firm Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP to undertake an internal investigation. The subsequent report, in July, concluded that while bank officials may have breached German privacy laws, they had not committed any major crimes.

Latest News

SHareholder meeting

ISSB sets direction for TNFD-aligned reporting

SHareholder meeting

2026 UK Proxy Season: targeted shareholder dissent yields boardroom fallouts

SHareholder meeting

Minerva Proxy Update

SHareholder meeting

SEC plans to dismantle shareholder governance infrastructure

SHareholder meeting

SFDR reset progresses, but credibility gaps remain

SHareholder meeting

China’s 80% ESG rule forces a reset for public funds

Featured Briefings

Minerva Briefing

UK Proxy Season Review 2026

Minerva Briefing

Australia Proxy Season Review 2025

Minerva Briefing

2026 Proxy Season Preview

Related Stories

Minerva Proxy Update

June 12, 2026
Read More
shareholder meetings and proxy voting

Minerva Proxy Update

June 5, 2026
Read More
Exon logo

ExxonMobil’s Texas redomicile passes with high dissent

June 5, 2026
Read More
AGM, Proxy Season, Shareholder Proposals

Minerva Proxy Update

May 29, 2026
Read More

Minerva Proxy Update

May 15, 2026
Read More