Companies upset by Australian remuneration report rebellions

13 November 2009

Sarah Wilson

EU regulation

The nickel producer and explorer, Western Areas, saw its remuneration report defeated at its AGM on 6 November, as Australia's stormy AGM season continues.The voting saw 52.5% vote against with a further 2.3% in abstentions. Four other remuneration-related resolutions were withdrawn in light of overwhelming opposition (by more than 2 to 1) from those voting by proxy ahead of the meeting.

The Company Secretary was critical of the voting outcome, stating that most of the votes against came from institutional shareholders via proxy advisory companies.

“These advisers do not really give any consideration to the style of company or the market capital. They apply the same standards to smaller miners and explorers companies as would to Wesfarmers, Woodside or BHP Billiton. We do not think the reasons behind the vote are justified as the board had actually recommended the report for approval.”

In Mining Daily, the Company Secretary explained that although corporate governance principles do not recommend non-executive director options, the company would rather conserve its cash for operational costs. The options would have been issued at a premium in excess of 50% of the share price.

“We would prefer to spend our money on drilling and exploration rather than higher fees for non-executive directors,” he said.

“So we reward them with things like options, because it aligns them with the shareholders. The shareholders want to see their capital grow and if that happens, the directors can be rewarded. We planned to use the options as a longer-term incentive to retain the directors on the board.”

Western Areas were not the only company to be upset with proxy advisory services, as the chairman of gold producer Kingsgate Consolidated criticised institutional investors for blindly following recommendations of voting advisory services. Kingsgate saw its remuneration report scrape through as the board used 6.3 million discretionary votes to turn around the voting outcome (otherwise 20.99m for, 23.03m against).

Chairman Ross Smyth-Kirk told the AGM that, ''unfortunately'', RiskMetrics had ''seen fit to recommend to its institutional clients that they vote against'' acceptance of the remuneration report.

'Whilst this is consistent with its recommendations for most companies, its analysis of your company is particularly flawed. That this tick-a-box mentality is so unquestioningly accepted by some institutions is even more disappointing and evokes emotional responses which open the issue to abuse.'

After AGM, Mr Smyth-Kirk told BusinessDay's reporter that he was not surprised by the seemingly blind acceptance of voting advice. ''It's like all of their decisions,'' he said. ''Everything relies on consultants. The institutions are getting further and further away from making decisions themselves.''

Further Reading

Mining Daily - Western Area story - Shareholders vote down director remuneration

BusinessDay - Kingsgate boss criticises pay vote



Latest News

SHareholder meeting

Texas pulls proxy advisor lawsuit as future of SB 2337 cases grows uncertain

SHareholder meeting

South Korea unveils platform to support online AGMs ahead of mandatory hybrid meeting rules

SHareholder meeting

Does the blue tsunami spell the end of the anti-ESG crusade?

SHareholder meeting

FCA finalises ESG ratings regime, bringing providers into regulatory framework

SHareholder meeting

ICCR, Ceres challenge Kentucky proxy advisor law

SHareholder meeting

Japan, Thailand and Brazil seek to expand sustainability information available to investors

Featured Briefings

Minerva Briefing

Australia 2026 AGM Season Preview

Minerva Briefing

2026 United States of America Proxy Season Review

Minerva Briefing

US SEC Rule 14a-8 Rescission Proposal

Minerva is a global provider of sustainable stewardship solutions with over 30 years of expertise. Minerva empowers investors by providing essential tools, including ESG research and data and expert insights, enabling them to navigate the intricate and ever-evolving landscape of stewardship and proxy voting, whilst ensuring their decisions are well-informed and aligned with sustainable principles.

Related Stories

 Baillie Gifford

Saba’s Baillie Gifford board challenge falls short, but pressure on trusts likely to persist

October 30, 2026
Read More
Procter & Gamble shareholder rights proposals

Procter & Gamble shareholder rights proposals draw significant support

October 22, 2026
Read More
Australia’s OpenAI breach

Australia’s OpenAI breach puts AI governance and board oversight under scrutiny

September 25, 2026
Read More
ASX Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations

ASX governance reform: simplification must preserve decision-useful disclosure

September 16, 2026
Read More
Australia consults on climate disclosure rollback

Australia consults on climate disclosure rollback

August 27, 2026
Read More
APAC Corporate Governance Reforms 2026

APAC corporate governance reforms: Japan and Australia shift focus to governance effectiveness

July 22, 2026
Read More