PCCW proxy ballot irregularities kill buyout

27 April 2009

Sarah Wilson

EU regulation

Hong Kong is not generally noted for its progressive corporate governance regime. Critics have argued that its weak regulatory system has long favoured powerful tycoons. However, in a rare and dramatic turn of events, Hong Kong's Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) has won its fight at the Court of Appeal to block PCCW chairman Richard Li's $US2.1 billion buyout to take the company private.

The SFC had alleged that the February 4th shareholder vote was rigged after hundreds of insurance agents were given PCCW stock - a practice known locally as “share splitting” - and then turned up to meeting and voted overwhelmingly in favour of the deal which would have seen small shareholders taken out at HK$4.50, substantially less than the principal shareholders who were to be paid a special dividend.

After a week-long hearing, the Appeal Court reversed the original ruling of High Court Judge Susan Kwan who had earlier rejected the SFC’s case. Kwan had branded the regulator’s allegations as “merely suspicion, wholly unsubstantiated by evidence”. According to local sources, a three-judge panel came to a unanimous decision to block the privatization after less than five minutes of deliberation.

SFC chief executive Martin Wheatley said that the Commission was still investigating the matter and would await the court’s written ruling before deciding whether “we need further law reforms”.

Congratulations are due to shareholder activist David Webb who lodged a complaint about the share splitting and vote rigging and acted as the trigger for The Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) to begin its probe.

Latest News

SHareholder meeting

Shareholders sue Intel amid share slump as investors increasingly turn to litigation

SHareholder meeting

Minerva Analytics Rule 14a-8 response urges SEC to preserve shareholder access through content-neutral proposal system

SHareholder meeting

SEC targets executive pay disclosures in planned broad governance reset

SHareholder meeting

Missouri sues proxy advisor over ESG voting recommendations

SHareholder meeting

Anthropic IPO raises disclosure and governance questions ahead of Nasdaq listing

SHareholder meeting

CSDDD consultation results sharpen investor focus on implementation

Featured Briefings

Minerva Briefing

2026 Europe Proxy Season Review

Minerva Briefing

Australia 2026 AGM Season Preview

Minerva Briefing

2026 United States of America Proxy Season Review

Minerva is a global provider of sustainable stewardship solutions with over 30 years of expertise. Minerva empowers investors by providing essential tools, including ESG research and data and expert insights, enabling them to navigate the intricate and ever-evolving landscape of stewardship and proxy voting, whilst ensuring their decisions are well-informed and aligned with sustainable principles.

Related Stories

Does the blue tsunami spell the end of the anti-ESG crusade?

November 5, 2026
Read More
Minerva Proxy Update

Minerva Proxy Update: Shareholder voting signals continued executive pay, board accountability focus

September 18, 2026
Read More
Investors urge SEC to reject Texas Stock Exchange voting rule

Investors urge SEC to reject Texas Stock Exchange voting rule

August 20, 2026
Read More
AGM and Proxy Voting

Minerva proxy update: AGM season slows as focus turns to Australia

July 10, 2026
Read More
Indiana and Proxy advisor restrictions

Indiana injunction marks third court setback for proxy advisor restrictions

July 1, 2026
Read More
Minerva Proxy Season Review 2026

2026 UK Proxy Season: Targeted shareholder dissent yields boardroom fallouts

June 26, 2026
Read More